Helfen statt Blockieren

Data, time series

Who has been sanctioning more, and since when? Sanction cases from 1914 to 2023

· Helfen statt Blockieren editorial team

In 1950, 18 sanction cases were in force worldwide; in 2023 there were 615. This analysis shows who started to sanction more and when, with which instruments and for which goals. It draws on three research datasets, and every figure can be recalculated from the files in the daten/ folder.

615active sanction cases in 2023, against 18 in 1950GSDB R4, own analysis
121new cases in 2023, more than ever beforeGSDB R4, own analysis
+88cases per year: trend 2019 to 2023GSDB R4, own analysis
46.5%US share of all active cases in 2023GSDB R4, own analysis

How many cases there are

Active and new sanction cases per year, 1950 to 2023

Active means in force in that year. New means imposed in that year. A case is a measure by one sender against one target for one reason, however many people or goods it covers.

Yearactive casesnew cases
19501818
1951257
1952273
1953260
19543410
1955302
1956302
1957335
1958354
1959331
1960378
1961396
19624612
19635916
1964579
19656211
1966646
19676510
19687210
1969723
1970703
1971675
1972611
19737821
1974848
19757613
1976766
19779019
19789814
197910615
1980904
1981979
198211526
19831076
19841035
19859310
198610215
198711318
19881148
198912417
199013629
199113625
199216148
199316733
199415818
199514325
199614927
199715221
199815527
199914917
200014922
200114816
200213521
200315536
200414110
200514620
200615934
200715713
200815712
200917329
201018124
201121747
201223940
201324723
201427646
201525716
201626116
201724230
201825231
201927136
202030544
2021400103
2022500119
2023615121

Source: GSDB Release 4, figures 1 and 5b, digitised by Helfen statt Blockieren (reference).

Until 1989 the stock grew steadily by about 2.6 cases per year (R² 0.95). From 1990 to 2009 it stayed almost flat (+0.5 per year): many Cold War cases ended while new ones were added, mainly by the UN and the EU. From 2010 to 2023 the stock rose by 23.2 cases per year, from 2019 to 2023 by 88.3. The best-fitting broken line bends in 2018 (in 2019 if only three instead of five years are required after the bend): +3.1 cases per year before, +70.3 after. On average 27.0 new cases a year were imposed in the 1990s and 96.8 in 2020 to 2023. The database authors explain the rise since 2019 by the fact that hardly any sanctions were lifted while many new ones were imposed, from 2022 mainly against Russia and Belarus (GSDB R4, GSDB R3).

Who sanctions, and since when more

Active sanction cases by sender, 1950 to 2023

Calculated from each sender’s share of all active cases (GSDB, figure 5b) times the number of active cases (figure 1). “Others” covers all other states and groups, including the United Kingdom, Russia, China, Canada, Japan and the Arab League; the figures do not show them separately.

YearUSEUUNothers
195060012
195190214
195290216
195380216
1954100123
195590120
1956110118
1957120120
1958130121
1959120120
1960150121
1961160122
1962210124
1963250232
1964240231
1965220337
1966200539
1967200540
1968240642
1969230643
1970230641
1971230638
1972200635
1973180654
1974190659
1975230548
1976260446
1977360549
1978381455
1979412459
1980390249
1981432250
1982434266
1983403262
1984382360
1985392349
1986415452
1987474458
1988464460
1989515464
1990568666
19915210866
199255171277
199358171478
199459181665
199560161156
199661201454
199763221552
199864241750
199959271647
200057262046
200159252143
200257261834
200369291740
200464261536
200556271944
200660262251
200760252250
200862252149
200962312159
201061292566
201172382780
201281423086
201387453283
2014895235100
201583483789
201685463694
201791383182
2018101363184
2019124352983
2020146412989
20211804729144
20222255530190
20232866729233

Source: GSDB Release 4, figures 1 and 5b, digitised by Helfen statt Blockieren (reference).

Slope of the linear trend 2019 to 2023, cases per year

Least squares over the five annual values; the table below gives all periods.

cases per year
US+40.3
EU+7.8
UN+0.1
others+40.1

Source: GSDB Release 4, figures 1 and 5b, digitised by Helfen statt Blockieren (reference).

Sender1950 to 19891990 to 20092010 to 20232019 to 2023Break yearbeforeafterabove 25 cases since
all2.560.5123.1988.3020183.1070.271952
US1.050.3013.5140.3020181.1737.271976
EU0.100.901.257.8019830.051.272009
UN0.080.660.000.1019850.090.812011
others1.34−1.358.4240.1020180.7927.061963

Slopes in cases per year. Break year: the year at which a line with one bend fits best (search over all years, at least eight years before and five after). For the EU a second bend fits in 2019 (+4.07 per year afterwards), for the UN in 2016 (−0.65 per year afterwards).

United States. Over the whole period the US was the largest single sender. From 1950 to 1989 the trend added about 1.1 active cases per year, from 1990 to 2009 only 0.3. From 2018 the increase accelerated to about 37 per year; the largest single-year increase came in 2023 (+61). The US share was 32.1% in 2014, 47.7% in 2020 and 46.5% in 2023. Many new US cases are targeted measures against individuals and companies rather than whole economies (GSDB R4).

European Union. The European Community appears as a joint sender from 1978; from 1983 its stock grew steadily, and faster from 2019 (+7.8 per year in 2019 to 2023), mainly through the packages against Russia and Belarus. In 2023 it had 67 active cases.

United Nations. The UN rarely imposed sanctions before 1990. After the deadlock in the Security Council ended, its stock rose to 37 by 2015; it has been falling since. The database authors point to vetoes, such as Russia’s veto against sanctions after the 2023 coup in Niger and against extending the sanctions on Mali (GSDB R4).

Others. This group grew until 1989, shrank until 2009 (−1.4 per year) and has risen steeply since 2018 to 2020 (depending on the calculation) (+40.1 per year in 2019 to 2023). The database names Russian counter-sanctions after the attack on Ukraine and, after Brexit, the United Kingdom’s own sanctions as the main drivers after 2020 (GSDB R4, GSDB R3).

The long line since 1914

New sanction cases per decade according to Hufbauer, Schott, Elliott, Oegg, 1914 to 2000

174 cases with a foreign policy goal; the start year is part of the case number (14-1 means 1914). The column “2000” covers the year 2000 only.

cases
1910s3
1920s2
1930s5
1940s9
1950s13
1960s21
1970s37
1980s31
1990s52
20001

Source: Hufbauer et al. 2007, table 1A.1; own count, checked against table 1.1 of the book.

New cases (threat or imposition) involving the sender, TIES 1945 to 2005

A case counts for every sender involved. TIES also counts threats that were never carried out, so the numbers are higher than in the other sources.

USUnited KingdomUSSR and RussiaChina
1945 to 1949241062
1950s521161
1960s7213103
1970s44932
1980s1173332
1990s277171313
2000 to 20051532362

Source: TIES 4.0, own analysis.

Before 1950 Hufbauer and co-authors record 19 cases, among them the British blockade of Germany in 1914 and the League of Nations measures against Italy in 1935. New cases rose from 13 in the 1950s to 52 in the 1990s. In 106 of the 174 cases the US is listed first among the senders. TIES shows the same movement with more cases because threats count as well: cases involving the US rose from 52 in the 1950s to 277 in the 1990s; the United Kingdom was most active in the 1980s (33), China in the 1990s (13), the Soviet Union and Russia in the 1960s and 1990s. Much on China is missing in the older datasets: the dedicated China collection by Zhang and Shanks counts 135 episodes with China as sender from 1949 to 2020, over 70 percent of them absent from earlier datasets (China TIES).

Which instruments are used

Active sanctions by type, 1950 to 2023

Stacked. One case can have several types, so the total exceeds the number of cases. Values on hover, tap or tab key every five years.

  • Trade
  • Arms
  • Military aid
  • Financial
  • Travel
  • Other
02505007501,0001,25019501960197019801990200020102023TradeFinancialTravel
Data as table
TypeShare 19501970199020102023Cases 2023Trend 2010 to 2023 per year
Trade61.9%27.2%24.3%18.7%21.2%257+9.7
Arms4.8%24.3%14.1%17.0%7.7%94+1.5
Military aid0.0%4.9%12.6%13.0%6.4%77+1.1
Financial9.6%19.4%33.0%25.2%36.4%441+18.9
Travel9.5%8.8%4.4%16.8%22.1%267+12.7
Other14.3%15.5%11.7%9.2%6.2%75+1.6

Source: GSDB Release 4, figure 2, digitised; annual values in daten/gsdb_r4_jahr.csv (reference).

In 1950, 61.9% of all measures were trade sanctions. In 2023 their share was 21.2%, although their number rose to 257. Financial sanctions (asset freezes, bans on dealings with banks) grew fastest, by about 19 a year since 2010, to 36.4% in 2023, followed by travel restrictions on individuals, from 4.4% (1990) to 22.1%. The researchers see this as a shift from comprehensive to targeted measures (GSDB R4).

What sanctions are meant to achieve

Goals of new cases per decade, shares in percent, TIES 1945 to 2005

A case can have up to three goals; each goal counts once. Mapping of the 15 TIES categories to six groups: see method.

  • Regime change
  • Human rights
  • Terrorism
  • Conflict and arms
  • Other policy
  • Trade dispute
0 %25 %50 %75 %100 %31 %28 %28 %1945/4924 %44 %16 %1950s13 %27 %37 %20 %1960s22 %17 %42 %1970s12 %17 %58 %1980s15 %74 %1990s39 %43 %2000/05
Data as table
DecadecasesRegime changeHuman rightsTerrorismConflict and armsOther policyTrade dispute
1945/4945422181616
1950s971125264717
1960s1312041415730
1970s1114287225514
1980s22632342942140
1990s547172632185426
2000/05255515323103114

Source: TIES 4.0, own analysis.

Goal by keyword (Hufbauer et al.)Cases 1914 to 19891990 to 2000total
Democracy21315
Human rights251237
Terrorism448
Conflict and arms391453
Regime change14115
Other policy37946

In TIES, conflict, arms and general policy dominate until the 1970s; human rights first become a major theme in the 1970s (28 goals). Trade disputes dominate the 1980s and 1990s because TIES also counts threats in tariff conflicts. In Hufbauer and co-authors, 13 of 53 cases from 1990 to 2000 name democracy as a goal, against 2 of 121 before 1990. For the years after 2005 there is no freely available count by goal. The GSDB describes for 1950 to 2022: sanctions for human rights rise steadily, those for territorial disputes and regime change decline; since the early 1990s sanctions against war and terrorism have grown, and sanctions to change a policy peaked in 2022 (GSDB R3).

Method and limits

GSDB. The Global Sanctions Data Base itself is only available on request, and its terms prohibit redistribution (website). The annual values here therefore come from the vector graphics of the public working paper on Release 4: each line has exactly one point per year, converted via the grid lines. Cross-checks with the text of the paper match: growth of active cases 31.1 instead of 31.2 percent in 2021, 25.0 and 23.0 percent in 2022 and 2023 as stated, US share 47.7 percent in 2020 (“peaking at 47%”); the four shares add up to 100 percent in every year. Values by type are accurate to about two cases. Release 5 of the Global Sanctions Data Base counts 1,794 cases from 1950 to the end of 2025; its data are available only on request. Annual figures for active cases (such as 615 in 2023) come from the published charts of Release 4 and run to 2023.

What is counted. A case says nothing about severity: a comprehensive embargo counts the same as an entry ban on one person. Rising case numbers therefore mainly mean more targeted measures.

TIES counts threats and impositions until 2005, Hufbauer et al. only larger cases with a foreign policy goal until 2000. The goal groups for Hufbauer et al. come from keywords in the goal column of the table (for example “democracy”, “human rights”, “terror”, “war”, “nuclear”) and are an approximation. TIES goals: regime change (code 3), human rights (8), terrorism and non-state actors (10), conflict and arms (2, 5, 6, 9), trade dispute (13, 14), other policy (1, 4, 7, 11, 12, 15).

Trends are descriptive. A break year does not prove a structural break; it shows where the slope changes most clearly.

Recalculate

Data for checking the figures (CSV): gsdb_r4_jahr.csv, ties4_faelle_nach_beginnjahr.csv, ties4_verhaengungen_nach_jahr.csv, ties4_art_nach_jahrzehnt.csv, ties4_ziele_nach_jahrzehnt.csv, hse_1914_2000_faelle.csv, ergebnis_trends_gsdb.csv, ergebnis_wendepunkte_gsdb.csv, ergebnis_arten_gsdb.csv, ergebnis_ties_akteure.csv, quellen_lizenzen.csv.

The tools for download, preparation and calculation are kept by the editorial team. We do not publish raw data from Global Trade Alert (licence CC BY-NC 4.0) or the folder of downloaded original files.

Continue: Economic bloc against economic bloc and the magazine chapter Blockades of the world economy.

Sources

  1. Yalcin, Felbermayr, Kariem, Kirilakha, Kwon, Syropoulos, Yotov: The Global Sanctions Data Base, Release 4. CGPA Working Paper 2025-02, Drexel University, 22 January 2025 (not peer reviewed). https://www.lebow.drexel.edu/sites/default/files/2025-01/wp2025002-global-sanctions-db-v2.pdf
  2. Syropoulos, Felbermayr, Kirilakha, Yalcin, Yotov: The Global Sanctions Data Base, Release 3. WIFO Working Paper 651, 2022; peer reviewed in Review of International Economics 32(1), 2024, pp. 12 to 48. https://www.wifo.ac.at/wp-content/uploads/upload-3619/wp_2022_651_.pdf
  3. Global Sanctions Data Base, website: access on request only, Release 5 with 1,794 cases to end 2025, redistribution prohibited. https://www.globalsanctionsdatabase.com/
  4. Morgan, Bapat, Kobayashi: Threat and Imposition of Economic Sanctions 1945 to 2005, Updating the TIES Dataset. Conflict Management and Peace Science 31(5), 2014, pp. 541 to 558; data TIES 4.0. https://sanctions.web.unc.edu/
  5. Zhang, Shanks: Measuring Chinese Economic Sanctions 1949 to 2020, Introducing the China TIES Dataset. Conflict Management and Peace Science 42(3), 2025, pp. 328 to 352. https://ideas.repec.org/a/sae/compsc/v42y2025i3p328-352.html
  6. Hufbauer, Schott, Elliott, Oegg: Economic Sanctions Reconsidered, 3rd edition, Peterson Institute 2007, chapter 1 (publisher preview), tables 1.1 and 1A.1. https://www.piie.com/publications/chapters_preview/4075/01iie4075.pdf